There are times when it’s very hard to stop doomscrolling and yet there’s nothing to actively do but bite your fingernails. That’s the time for the books that will take you out of this world, and into another that will have problems of its own that will be so absorbing that you can forget, for a little while, the problems that surround you. People have sometimes emailed me saying that they read one of my novels at the deathbed of a relative, and thanking me, and I have over time developed a response to this which is “I’m very sorry you needed it, and I’m very glad it was there for you when you did.”
This is a list of things I’ve found that work for me when that’s what I need. It’s related to comfort reading and books where no bad things happen, but subtly different, and the quality these books really need is to be very grabby, so you really want to read the next line, and the next, and so on. There are a lot of books (some of which I absolutely love) that take some effort to get into, so if you were halfway through them already, they’d be perfect, but these are ones that grab you from the word go. I’m trying to think of things across a range of genres so you haven’t read them all already. They’re in no sort of order. And needless to say, this is far from a complete list, please add things in comments…
Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City — K.J. Parker (2019) This was the book that broke my reading slump during lockdown. I was reading, but I had to keep forcing myself to concentrate. This just did the thing where I wasn’t thinking about myself and this world but the problem of finding a sixteenth way to defend a walled city. This is a fantasy novel without magic, written in first person confidential, where the reader is being confided in, in an imaginary history with very fun logistics and military technology. It may not be for everyone, but nothing is for everyone. It was just what I needed.
Under Italian Skies — Nicky Pellegrino (2017) This is a romance novel set in Italy, and it’s very well written and the romance is almost off the page; it’s about a woman going to Italy and everything being OK. There are other books in this category, like Elizabeth von Arnim’s The Enchanted April and indeed other books by Pellegrino, but if you’re just going to read one, try this one.
Wild Seed — Octavia Butler (1980) This is one where the problems the characters have will help you forget your own. Absolutely unputdownable book about an Igbo shapechanger and an Egyptian man who can jump between bodies, and their relationship over a whole lot of time.
Fangirl — Rainbow Rowell (2013) YA novel about a fanfiction writer going to college and growing up. It’s brilliantly written and very grabby, like all Rowell, and in this one she does wonderful things with giving us bits of the texts and the fanfiction to illuminate the story. You may also like her other books, which are also great.
The Warrior’s Apprentice — Lois McMaster Bujold (1986) The first of the Miles Vorkosigan books, and while they get better, this one is a great place to start. We’re on the planet of Barrayar, in the future, and young Miles wants to go to military academy, but this isn’t that sort of book. So absorbing that I once read this in the bath until the water went unpleasantly cold.
The Husbands — Holly Gramazio (2024) I just read this, and I really just wanted to keep reading it straight through without pausing and was sorry when I finished it. Lauren comes home from a party to discover her husband waiting – but she’s unmarried and she’s never seen him before. And when he goes up to the attic he vanishes and a different husband comes down, and whenever she wants to get rid of a husband and change her life, she can just send him up to the attic… Well-thought-through science fiction premise used for a small-scale story.
Double Star — Robert A. Heinlein (1956) A washed-up actor gets a job standing in for a politician, shenanigans ensue on Mars, in space, and on the Moon. Written in the first-person perspective of a slightly vain actor who is unreliable in that he doesn’t entirely see how much he is being entirely taken over. In my opinion, this is Heinlein’s best novel.
Black Swan Green — David Mitchell (2006) You don’t need to have read anything else in Mitchell’s Thousand Autumns series to read this; it is embedded in it but stands alone. It’s the first-person story of a teenage boy with a stutter in England in the 1980s and his parents are breaking up and he lives in a village and everything is agony, especially getting words to come out of his mouth.
Never Let Me Go — Kazuo Ishiguro (2005) There are things wrong with the science of this book, but the voice is perfect. Ishiguro uses the mode of privilege to talk about dystopia in a very clever way, and it’s really worth reading.
Thus Was Adonis Murdered — Sarah Caudwell (1981) Charming epistolary murder mystery, very readable.
Piranesi — Susanna Clarke (2019) Beautifully written and very gripping story of a man living in a giant house full of statues and tides. It’s so hard to describe what makes it so great, but it’s the first-person point of view of a wonderful but very strange person who is childlike but not childish, living in a world that is magical in ways in which we do not usually read magic.
Rimrunners — C.J. Cherryh (1989) The Locus review said “never a dull moment and rarely a safe one.” Lots of terrible things happen in this book—it’s the opposite of a comfort read, but it’s Cherryh at her most grabby and your own problems may disappear into a small speck in the distance compared to what’s happening to the characters.
Derring-Do For Beginners — Victoria Goddard (2023) Totally the opposite, a real feel-good fantasy about friendship and travel across fantasy worlds.
Thanks for the recommendations:
Small typo: It’s *The* Husbands
Fixed, thank you.
I love your concept of “grabbyness” as orthogonal to quality and have used it a lot since I learned of it. My most recent super grabby book series was Adrian Tchaikovsky’s final architecture series. It’s far from his best work and it’s really a space fantasy more than anything else, but I couldn’t put it down.
My go-to comfort book is always “The Bridge of Birds” by Barry Hughart. Clever, funny and in the end everyone gets their happy end (sorry for that spoiler, but this should be clear in this context).
I haven’t re-read that in forever, thank you for reminding me of it!
I agree with Ms. Walton about Double Star, although I would not classify Lorenzo Smythe as slightly vain.
Thank you for this list. My favourite recent unputdownable books are Everina Maxwell’s Winter’s Orbit and Ocean’s Echo.
Almost everything by Goddard really. Speaking of Vorkosigan, I’m currently rereading Captain Vorpatril’s Alliance, in which absolutely nothing seriously bad happens to anyone. It’s made of spoilers for those who haven’t read the series, though.
If you want to lose yourself for a few days or a few years, try Terry Pratchett’s Discworld.
For the uninitiated, I’d recommend starting with the City Watch series beginning with Guards, Guards.
I love any Pratchett with Sam Vimes – or Granny Weatherwax.
I was going to say Piranesi, but since you got there first, how about Home Cooking by Laurie Colwin? Low-key essays about food and cooking with a light touch and some solid but simple recipes. Doesn’t sound “grabby” but I have read it straight through many times. Or maybe you need some science/nature writing to make you remember that there are many beautiful things out there. H is for Hawk by Helen MacDonald, or An Immense World by Ed Yong are both good picks. Or how about some queer horror? Camp Damascus by Chuck Tingle is very grabby if you like that kind of thing.
I’m a big fan of Laurie Colwin, so it’s nice to see her get called out here. More Home Cooking is a second collection of her food writing. She was also an excellent novelist and short-story writer.
I just bought Home Cooking, which looks great. Thank you.
My recommendations:
The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison – one of my go-to books whenever I need to get away from my own problems.
The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows. (There is also a movie based on this book, but I haven’t seen it yet, so what I’m gonig to say here is strictliy about the novel, which I read for the first time long before the film was made.)
The book is set first in London and then on the channel island Guernsey, shortly after World War II. It’s an epistolary novel, which makes it very grabby (“I’m just going to read one more letter … maybe the next one , too … oh, just one more”) and each writer (the letters are from a lot of different people) has a distinct voice.
During the time in which the book is set, nothing too bad happens, but many letters deal with what was going on during WW II, which is often harrowing – it is one of the few books that makes me cry during reading, so you might want to be careful while reading it.
The novel is also a love letter to books and reading and to the power stories have to helo us during bad times, and for me it is a reminder how resilient we can be and that humanity has gone through horrible things before and managed to come out again and to rebuild and recover, even at great cost.
The Goblin Emperor is also a wonderful audiobook- it’s helped me through some sleepless nights.
This may be slightly tangential, but I’ve recently been reading Brian Blessed’s autobiography ‘Absolute Pandemonium’ and it’s hilarious. The audiobook is even better, as it’s narrated by Brian himself, so you can imagine what that’s like.
I would add my recommendations of The Comfortable Courtesan by L.A. Hall. It’s the first in a series of quick and easy reads, and I’m enchanted by the way in which the titular courtesan is a schemer, but not in the same way I normally see in fiction.
Alternatively, I also recommend Tuyo by Rachel Neumeier which is a less relaxing read, but once I got started, I couldn’t stop. I ended up reading it all in one sitting, despite the headache I got from looking up close for too long.
For escapist reads, I like series so I can keep reading a little longer if I so choose.
For enjoyers of fanfiction, I recommend The Pureblood Pretense by murkybluematter which is a long running Harry Potter / Alanna the Lioness fic on fanfiction.net or The Grand Unified Theory of Shen Qingqiu by 00janeblonde for pedagogy, yearning, and time travel in ancient china-inspired fantasy.
I very much enjoyed the first 12 books of the Comfortable Courtesan series, though I have become quite lost in the endless sequels after them.
I have two words plus four words for you – “Robin Hobb” and “Realm of the Elderlings”.
I’m putting a lot of stuff on this list (and this comment thread) on my wishlist for Christmas.
Also, I just finished reading Tanith Lee’s “Piratica” earlier this week, and it was really fun, plus I was terribly tempted to sneak it into work with me so I could keep reading it…
The Aunt Dimity mysteries. Cozy by way of a ghostly diary. There is never a murder. The point is to find out more about the person and why something happened. (Why they are alone or why they were found in a snowbank . . .) It’s set in a small village in England and there is a lot of matchmaking and people interfering for all the best reasons.
Swordheart is another of my go-tos. A mostly low-stakes story in a fun, whimsical (but also serious) setting, a sweet middle-aged romance, and the first appearance of Zale, Holy Lawyer and (Public) Defender of the Downtrodden.
When the Angels Left the Old Country too, a deeply heartwarming tale of angels, demons, lesbians, and labor organizing set in the Pale of Settlement and NYC at the turn of the last century.
T. Kingfisher is an absolute gem and does not get talked about enough imo
I have the White Rat tattooed on my shoulder, needless to say I am a big fan
Or What You Will, by Jo Walton, is one of my newer comfort reads.
Oh thank you! It’s always nice to hear that. And I’ve almost finished a new novel!
Wonderful news! Hope it comes to my hands quickly!
Thanks for another interesting list, I even enjoy reading about the books I know I’ll never read.
Rimrunners is one of my favourite Cherryh’s. I find most, but not all, of her books grabby; there are some, though, that I have bounced off hard. I’m trying to think of one that isn’t intense from the get go, and I’m struggling to think of one. Hestia, maybe, which I read when the DAW pb came out, and not since; all I recall is being v disappointed, & not liking it.
I agree, the list is great to find reads I may have missed. I’m always happy to see C.J. Cherryh on a list, the Company Wars series in particular is always an engaging read.
I also have a warm place in my heart for Andre Norton’s books, especially the Solar Queen series. I discovered Ms. Norton when I was a schoolboy, and she was one of the authors that gave me a love for science fiction and literature in general.
Cherryh’s Foreigner series didn’t grab me, and that’s a lot of her recent output. But she just put out a second new Union/Alliance book, “Alliance Unbound” (following up “Alliance Rising”), and I found that to be reasonably absorbing.
Probably best to read the new ones with some distance from Downbelow Station, since the history doesn’t fully line up. (I can headcanon Doylist or Watsonian reasons for that, but I suspect it comes down to the author not choosing to be bound by what she wrote forty years ago.) But the characters and situation are engaging.
(Though it has somewhat in common with A Deepness in the Sky insofar as if you’ve read elsewhere in that world, you know something about the future and the outcome of their efforts that the characters don’t.)
To me Piranesi was a very depressing book. Maybe the comfort is in the idea that things could always be worse?
The house is cold and wet, and the narrator has been tricked into going there. When there he loses his memory. He says he loves the place, but to me it seems horrible.
I didn’t say comfort books, I said books that will make you keep reading. Rimrunners is very uncomforting.
SPOILERS FOR PIRANESI
But I feel that the joy of the narrator’s voice in Piranesi of who he has become after being tricked through the portal, the way he loves it and cherishes it and understands it. It can be hell for other people, but it can be a marvel and he has accepted it and found it so. His attitude and how he lives with it is what I find full of joy. I don’t see him as Matthew Rose Sorenson who has lost his memory but as the Beloved Child of the House who has a mysterious and forgotten past — and that’s how we’re presented with it in the book. It might seem horrible to you, and I’d be very uncomfortable there, and if someone had described it to me I’d have thought it sounded depressing, but I love the way he has found the joy in it, and I admire the way Clarke has written the book to centre that.
I LOVED Piranesi! “Gentle joy” is a perfect description of the narrator. He is content with his lot and his routine – not many of us can say that!
Piranesi, I have decided, is my favorite fantasy novel of the new millennium. I also endorse 16 Ways, Double Star, and almost any early Bujold. (I still love Shards of Honor as a starting point, simply perhaps because that’s where I started.)
Other recommendations: any Trollope (perhaps Barchester Towers is a good choice.) Engine Summer. The Last Unicorn. Frederika.
And you remind me that I really need to get to Black Swan Green!
So glad to see Black swan Green on the list – very underrated and probably my favorite book by Mitchell (and Ive read them all).
The bookseller at the end of the world is a very nice (true) autobiography from the owner of a small bookshop. Its very wholesome.
With fiction Ive only now discovered the Steerswomen books (Rosemary Kirstein) and they are also very recommended.
A bit lighter and more chaotic still: The Tatami galaxy by Tomihiko Morimi. The first chapter is a bit difficult to get into, in the sense of “Why should I read this?”, but by the second you do a double take and then it keeps getting better and really makes your smile.
I’m so, so happy that someone has finally put “Thus Was Adonis Murdered” on a Best Of list – the characters, the plot, the writing, the mystery of Hilary – anything by Sarah Caldwell, who sadly left the planet way too soon!
I have found the Liaden books of Lee and Miller to be very grabby, as well as Wen Spencer’s Tinker series.
Wen Spencer doesn’t get enough mention IMO. Have you read the Ukiah Oregon books?
Wonderful list – I mean, I saw three I agreed about, and opened my library hold list to add almost all the others. Thank you!
Books I’ve encountered recently that sucked me in:
Run Towards the Danger – Sarah Polley, memoir essays.
Romantic Comedy – Curtis Sittenfeld, novel about being a woman in a TV show writers’ room, felt like 30 Rock.
Welcome to the School by the Sea et. seq.- Jenny Colgan, boarding-school stories that are like Enid Blyton for grownups.
Rereads that distracted me from overdue library books:
Death at the Dolphin, Light Thickens – Ngaio Marsh, classic murder mysteries with theatre setting.
Fluid State – Rob Browatske, gay romance.
Jo: thank you for this list! Several added to Mt. TBR, and I’ve been promoting your post over at Goodreads.
I have a couple of adds, from my 100 Best list over there:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/8101737-peter-tillman?ref=nav_mybooks&shelf=favorites
The Sand-Reckoner by Gillian Bradshaw
Historical fiction doesn’t get much better than this. Very likely Bradshaw’s masterwork.
For SF/F readers: Think Ken MacLeod, in the days of the Roman Republic. High-order engineering and political fiction, with war & romance. Wonderful stuff. 5 stars!
UK Le Guin’s novella, “Buffalo Gals, Won’t You Come Out Tonight,” which is wonderful. Le Guin at her very best. Won the Hugo (for best novelette) and World Fantasy awards, 1988.
Wow. I could re-re-read this every year! Jo, your bath-water wouldn’t even get cold.
Untethered Sky by Fonda Lee, 2023. Here’s Marissa Lingen’s short review, in its entirety:
“Vivid fun novella of rocs and their hunting handlers. Monsters monsters rawr yay.”
Why I keep reading her stuff. The perfect teaser for a near-perfect short book.
Hot Water by P.G. Wodehouse, 1932. Typical brilliant PGW romantic farce. Great stuff. I have teasers here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2110177471
Deep enough!
I have been burying myself in Jodi Taylor’s The Chronicles of St Marys (and tangential Time Police ) series. Not only are the books themselves wonderful fun, seeing all the threads slowly coming together across the entirety of the work (14 St Marys novels and 3 short story anthologies, 5 Time Police novels and a new, second spin off just out). So much to lose yourself in!
I enjoy rereading Steven Brust’s Jhereg series as most of the books are grabby. Also Martha Wells Murderbot series, Ilona Andrews Innkeeper and Hidden Legacy series are very grabby.
I now have bookmarked this article so I can increase my TBR pile. So many good recommendations!
Definitely recommend The Goblin Emperor. I will add two: The House in the Cerulean Sea by T.J. Klune and A Psalm for the Wild-Built by Becky Chambers. I love these books so much but the series I often go back to when I desperately need comfort starts thusly:
“THE FIRST THING the boy Garion remembered was the kitchen at Faldor’s farm.” I suspect thought that Psalm will move further up the list as time goes by.
Thanks for the very timely list. I was laid off in September, so I was already in a mode of wanting mostly comfort reading (grabby is good, but lately even books that I found grabby in the past aren’t grabby now unless they also fall into the comfort category:
T. Kingfisher’s Saint of Steel series plus A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking and Swordheart
Victoria Goddard’s Greenwing & Dart series. Her Lays of the Hearthfire series would also be good but I reread that over the summer.
Quenby Olsen’s Miss Percy series
I Heard the Owl Call My Name by Margaret Craven
Lois McMaster Bujold’s Penric books
Thanks for a wonderful post, Jo! I’ve added a number of titles to my investigate list.
Books that I find grabby include:
Stray by Andrea Höst (told totally in journal entries)
Linesman by S.K. Dunstall
The Goblin Emperor by Katherine Addison
Uhura’s Song by Janet Kagan